geoscience.net logo
+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

The excess of childhood leukaemia near Sellafield: A commentary on the fourth COMARE report


, : The excess of childhood leukaemia near Sellafield: A commentary on the fourth COMARE report. Journal of Radiological Protection 17(2): 63-71

Problems in investigating disease clusters are illustrated by the latest (fourth) report of the Committee on Medical Aspects of Radiation in the Environment (COMARE) on the excess of leukaemia and non-Hodgkin lymphoma among young people living near the Sellafield nuclear installation in West Cumbria, England. COMARE found no evidence that exposure to radiation could account for this excess and examined alternative explanations. The Report discusses inter alia the hypothesis that these diseases have an infective aetiology promoted by population mixing and considers the relevance of such mixing to the Sellafield area. It concludes that infection cannot be the sole explanation for the excess of cases, implying that some other causative factor (possibly radiation) must also be operating. This conclusion is, however, largely the result of arbitrarily concentrating attention on the village of Seascale (where the excess had initially been observed) rather than the entire vicinity of Sellafield, the putative cause of the excess. This well known pitfall exaggerates the significance of the Seascale excess. The Report then contrasts the magnitude of this excess in Seascale with those in much larger study areas away from Sellafield that were chosen (independently of leukaemia data) because of their relevance to population mixing; but this is not a comparison of like with like. When the Report does consider an area that includes Sellafield, the area chosen is so large (over 700 sq miles) as to 'dilute out' localised excesses. COMARE underestimates the special factors that would account, under the infection hypothesis, for the unusually large excess in Seascale, and pays insufficient attention to other communities near Sellafield which may have been affected by population mixing.

US$19.90

DOI: 10.1088/0952-4746/17/2/003


Other references

Matula, T.I.; Srivastava, V.S.; Wong, P.; Macleod, R.A., 1970: Transport and retention of potassium ion and other metabolites in a marine pseudomonad and their relation to the mechanism of optical effects. Journal of Bacteriology 102(3): 790-796

Nelson, J.A.; Kim, E.M.; Serletti, J.M.; Wu, L.C., 2010: A novel technique for lower extremity limb salvage: the vastus lateralis muscle flap with concurrent use of the vacuum-assisted closure device. Free tissue transfer is an essential component of lower extremity limb reconstruction and has dramatically improved salvage attempts. In this report, we examine the use of the underutilized free vastus lateralis muscle flap and describe our treatm...

Midelfort, C.F.; Gupta, R.K.; Meloche, H.P., 1977: Specificity of 2-keto-3-deoxygluconate-6-P aldolase for open chain form of 2-keto-3-deoxygluconate-6-P. 2-Keto-3-deoxygluconate-6-P exists as an euqilibrium of three forms at 25 degrees measurable by 13C NMR: alpha-furanose anomer (41%), beta-furanose anomer (50%), and open chain keto (9%). The three forms are interconverted rapidly (greater than 0....

Muqim, R-ul.; Naz, T., 2004: Urethral diverticulum in female. A case of 50 years old female with a urethral diverticulum is presented. The diagnosis was delayed for many years, it was successfully treated by performing transvaginal diverticulectomy.

Senter, P.D.; Svensson, H.P., 1996: A summary of monoclonal antibody-enzyme/prodrug. A great deal of research has surrounded the use of monoclonal antibody-enzyme conjugates for the activation of anticancer prodrugs. This is a two-step approach to cancer chemotherapy in which monoclonal antibodies are used to deliver enzymes to tu...

Ferrari, M.G.; Marino, F.; Montresor, E.; Abrescia, F.; Negri, S.; Briani, G.F.; Bertrand, C.; Puchetti, V., 1987: Esophageal localization of granulosa cell tumor (presentation of a clinical case). The authors report on a case of granular cell tumour localized in the lower third of the thoracic oesophagus. The patient, a 49-year-old male, suffering from symptoms of dysphagia over the previous few months, was treated surgically by thoracotomy...

Martinović, D.; Hogarth, W.T.; Jones, R.E.; Sorensen, P.W., 2007: Environmental estrogens suppress hormones, behavior, and reproductive fitness in male fathead minnows. This study explored the possibility that environmental estrogens in sewage effluent may reduce the reproductive fitness of adult male fish by suppressing their reproductive behaviors, including their ability to compete for nests and females. Male...

Kostyuchenko, A.D.; Listvin, K.S.; Petrova, L.I., 1952: The use of granular fertilizers for flax.. Granular super. or organo-super. granules increased yields of flax receiving PK particularly when applied in the row with the seed at the rate of 10 kg./ha. of P2O5. Organo-mineral granules applied in the row with the seed were very effective. The...

Anonymous, 1962: The sequence hypothesis. Review of recent advances on the problem of how genes control development.

Wauters, J.P.; Rossel, C.; Farquet, J.J., 1978: Amanita phalloides poisoning treated by early charcoal haemoperfusion. Four men and 4 women, aged 16-55 yr, were admitted after eating mushrooms 16 h earlier and they all had severe gastrointestinal symptoms. All patients except the one who had eaten only a small amount of A. phalloides were treated with haemoperfusi...