geoscience.net logo
+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Foundations of the new phylogenetics


, : Foundations of the new phylogenetics. Zhurnal Obshchei Biologii 65(4): 334-366

Evolutionary idea is the core of the modem biology. Due to this, phylogenetics dealing with historical reconstructions in biology takes a priority position among biological disciplines. The second half of the 20th century witnessed growth of a great interest to phylogenetic reconstructions at macrotaxonomic level which replaced microevolutionary studies dominating during the 30s-60s. This meant shift from population thinking to phylogenetic one but it was not revival of the classical phylogenetics; rather, a new approach emerged that was baptized The New Phylogenetics. It arose as a result of merging of three disciplines which were developing independently during 60s-70s, namely cladistics, numerical phyletics, and molecular phylogenetics (now basically genophyletics). Thus, the new phylogenetics could be defined as a branch of evolutionary biology aimed at elaboration of "parsimonious" cladistic hypotheses by means of numerical methods on the basis of mostly molecular data. Classical phylogenetics, as a historical predecessor of the new one, emerged on the basis of the naturphilosophical worldview which included a superorganismal idea of biota. Accordingly to that view, historical development (the phylogeny) was thought an analogy of individual one (the ontogeny) so its most basical features were progressive parallel developments of "parts" (taxa), supplemented with Darwinian concept of monophyly. Two predominating traditions were diverged within classical phylogenetics according to a particular interpretation of relation between these concepts. One of them (Cope, Severtzow) belittled monophyly and paid most attention to progressive parallel developments of morphological traits. Such an attitude turned this kind of phylogenetics to be rather the semogenetics dealing primarily with evolution of structures and not of taxa. Another tradition (Haeckel) considered both monophyletic and parallel origins of taxa jointly: in the middle of 20th century it was splitted into phylistics (Rasnitsyn's term; close to Simpsonian evolutionary taxonomy) belonging rather to the classical realm, and Hennigian cladistics that pays attention to origin of monophyletic taxa exclusively. In early of the 20th century, microevolutionary doctrine became predominating in evolutionary studies. Its core is the population thinking accompanied by the phenetic one based on equation of kinship to overall similarity. They were connected to positivist philosophy and hence were characterized by reductionism at both ontological and epistemological levels. It lead to fall of classical phylogenetics but created the prerequisites for the new phylogenetics which also appeared to be full of reductionism. The new rise of phylogenetic (rather than tree) thinking during the last third of the 20th century was caused by lost of explanatory power of population one and by development of the new worldview and new epistemological premises. That new worldview is based on the synergetic (Prigoginian) model of development of non-equilibrium systems: evolution of the biota, a part of which is phylogeny, is considered as such a development. At epistemological level, the principal premise appeared to be fall of positivism which was replaced by post-positivism argumentation schemes.Input of cladistics into new phylogenetics is twofold. On the one hand, it reduced phylogeny to cladistic history lacking any adaptivist interpretation and presuming minimal evolution model. From this it followed reduction of kinship relation to sister-group relation lacking any reference to real time scale and to ancestor-descendant relation. On the other hand, cladistics elaborated methodology of phylogenetic reconstructions based on the synapomorphy principle, the outgroup concept became its part. The both inputs served as premises of incorporation of both numerical techniques and molecular data into phylogenetic reconstruction. Numerical phyletics provided the new phylogenetics with easily manipulated algorithms of cladogram construing and thus made phylogenetic reconstructions operational and repetitive. The above phenetic formula "kinship=Similarity" appeared to be a keystone for development of the genophyletics. Within numerical phyletics, a lot of computer programs were elaborated which allow to manipulate with evolutionary scenario during phylogenetic reconstructions. They make it possible to reconstruct both clado- and semogeneses based on the same formalized methods. Multiplicity of numerical approaches indicates that, just as in the case of numerical phenetics, choice of adequate method(s) should be based on biologically sound theory. The main input of genophyletics (=molecular phylogenetics) into the new phylogenetics was due to completely new factology which makes it possible to compare directly such far distant taxa as prokaryotes and higher eukaryotes. Genophyletics is based on the theory of neutral evolution borrowed from microevolutionary theory and on the molecular clo ck hypothesis which is now considered largely inadequate. The future developments of genophyletics will be aimed at clarification of such fundamental (and "classical" by origin) problems as application of character and homology concepts to molecular structures. The new phylogenetics itself is differentiated into several schools caused basically by diversity of various approaches existing within each of its "roots". Cladistics makes new phylogenetics splitted into evolutionary and parsimonious ontological viewpoints. Numerical phyletics divides it into statistical and (again) parsimonious methodologies. Molecular phylogenetics is opposite by its factological basis to morphological one. The new phylogenetics has significance impact onto the "newest" systematics. From one side, it gives ontological status back to macrotaxa they have lost due to "new" systematics based on population thinking. From another side, it rejects some basical principles of classical phylogenetic (originally L

US$29.90

PMID: 15490579


Other references

Figler, Mária.; Mózsik, G.; Schaffer, Béla.; Gasztonyi, Báta.; Acs, Pác.; Szili, Béla.; Rab, R.; Szakály, Sándor., 2006: Effect of special Hungarian probiotic kefir on faecal microflora. AIM: To investigate the effect of a four-week consumption of a special Hungarian probiotic agent (BiofirReg.) on the faecal microflora in human healthy subjects. METHODS: The effect of BiofirReg. with 106/cm3 initial germs on the faecal microflora...

Trikka Graphakos, E.; Salem, Z.; Charalambakis, N.; Nepka, M.; Pappas, C.; Ioannidou, F., 2003: Serositis as a complication of septicaemia, without meningitis, caused by N meningitidis A case report. FEMS Congress of European Microbiologists Abstract Book (1): 253

Kabuga, J.D., 1992: Social relationships in N'dama cattle during supplementary feeding. Social relationships of 30 N'dama cows during supplementary feeding, post-grazing, were studied over 1.5 years. Dominance ranks determined during idling and feeding periods were strongly correlated (Spearman's rank correlation (rs=0.964)...

Coch Nicholas K.; Krinsley David H., 1971: Comparison of stratigraphic and electron microscopic studies in Virginia Pleistocene coastal sediments. Journal of Geology 79(4): 426-437

Gunderson, N.O., 2010: Statistical aspects of the 1945 poliomyelitis epidemic Rockford, Illinois. Bulletin. Chicago Medical Society 49: 59-59

Krishnamurthy, S.; Bai, N.J.; George, T., 1984: Mechanism of oxidative lysis and lipid peroxidation of vitamin E-deficient erythrocytes. Indian Journal of Biochemistry & Biophysics 21(6): 361-364

Walker, B.R., 1983: Antidiuresis and decreased sodium excretion during cyclo-oxygenase inhibition in the conscious dog. Studies were undertaken to further elucidate the role of endogenous prostaglandins in normal renal function in the awake dog. Meclofenamate (2 mg/kg and 2 mg/kg/h, i.v.) was administered after control measurements. Parallel time control experiment...

Chapnick, P.; Matchett, R.W.; Baker, G.I., 1968: Hyperparathyroidism: review and case report. Journal of the Canadian Dental Association 34(7): 361-366

Koay, P.Y.; McGhee, C.N.; Crawford, G.J., 2000: Effect of a standard paired arcuate incision and augmentation sutures on postkeratoplasty astigmatism. To analyze the efficacy of a standardized paired arcuate incision and augmentation suture technique in the treatment of various levels of post-penetrating keratoplasty (PKP) astigmatism. Lions Eye Institute, Royal Perth Hospital, Perth, Australia,...

Loos Frank, B., 1971: Zur Trematodenfauna der Silbermowe (Lardsargentatus) an der sudlichen Nordsee. Vogelwarte: 202-212