geoscience.net logo
+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Evaluating the Estimation of Fishery Management Reference Points in a Variable Environment


, : Evaluating the Estimation of Fishery Management Reference Points in a Variable Environment. Fisheries Research 100(1): 0-56

There is strong evidence that low frequency between-year environmental variability, in addition to fishing, is able to affect fish population abundance via recruitment. However, scientific advice regarding catch limits is often based on control rules that depend on the estimation of biomass reference points which typically do not explicitly consider the effects of trends over time in reference points caused by environmental variability. Harvest rates based on commonly used biological reference points such as the level of unfished spawning biomass (B0), the current size of the stock in relation to B0, and BMSY that are sustainable under current environmental conditions may be unsustainable under different environmental conditions. Although several methods exist for estimating biomass reference points, it is unclear which of these are most robust to the effects of long term, low frequency environmental variability. Therefore, simulation is used to evaluate alternative estimators, which differ in terms of how the stock–recruitment relationship is modeled, and whether explicit estimators or proxies are used for B0, the steepness of the stock–recruitment relationship, and current spawning biomass relative to B0. The simulations consider three life histories: a long-lived unproductive rockfish, a moderately long-lived and productive flatfish, and a moderately long-lived and productive hake with highly variable recruitment. Results indicate that in the presence of low frequency autocorrelated forcing of recruitment, biomass reference points should be based on average recruitment and/or dynamic B0 if catch and survey data are available for at least one full period of the environmental variable. In contrast, previous analysis suggests that in the absence of autocorrelated environmental forcing of recruitment, and if the available catch and survey data do not span at least, in this case, 50 years which is one full period of the environmental variable, biomass reference points should be based on the fit of the stock–recruitment relationship. Life history affects the estimability of biomass reference points, which are more difficult to estimate for species with more rapid dynamics such as hake. The method used to calculate the reference points given the results of a stock assessment has a larger effect on estimability than the configuration of the stock assessment method, for the three stock assessment model configurations investigated in this study.

US$19.90

DOI: 10.1016/j.fishres.2009.03.001


Other references

Keefer, C.E., 1946: A new method of heating sludge digesters. Direct heating of digestion tanks by submerged gas burners is described. The heating equipment consists of a carburetor and gas burner which may be of the open or the closed type. The motor-driven carburetor mixes digester gas and air and pumps it...

Bourgeois, J., 1908: Malacodermata. Unknown

Bent, A., 2012: Fellow lecture series. Female Pelvic Medicine & Reconstructive Surgery 17(6): 263-263

Liu Jie, Z.Y.juan; D.H.ngqing, 1997: A study on the quality criteria for Bazhen Shennongyin Liquor. Radix Angelicae Sinensis, Radix Paeoniae Alba and Radix et Rhizoma Rhei in Bazhen Shengnongyin Liquor were identified by TLC. The contents of ginsenoside Rb-1 in the preparation was determined by TLCS. Simple, accurate and reproducible, this metho...

Kreyberg, L., 1961: Exploratory excisions during surgery. Nordisk Medicin 65: 933-935

Hafez M.; E.S.id L., 1970: On the bionomics of orgyia dubia judaea lepidoptera lymantriidae. Bulletin de la Societe Entomologique d'Egypte 53: 161-183

Koren, E.; Cooper, D.K.C., 1996: Method of inhibiting acute complement mediated cytotoxicity with anti-idiotypic antibodies. Official Gazette of the United States Patent & Trademark Office Patents 1191(1): 312, Oct 1

Niemann, S.; Weiss, S., 2011: Attachment Behavior of Children Adopted Internationally at Six Months Post Adoption. The purpose of this pilot study was to describe attachment behavior in children adopted internationally at 6 months post adoption. Twenty-two children and their adoptive mothers were observed at home for completion of an attachment measure. Mother...

Hertogen Jan, 1981: Chemical composition of differentiated Antarctic meteorites. Meteoritics: , Pages 326. 1981.

Bellokossy, F.K., 1967: In our defense. Journal of the American Institute of Homeopathy 60(1): 27-33