+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Misconceived causal explanations for emergent processes

, : Misconceived causal explanations for emergent processes. Cognitive Science 36(1): 1-61

Studies exploring how students learn and understand science processes such as diffusion and natural selection typically find that students provide misconceived explanations of how the patterns of such processes arise (such as why giraffes' necks get longer over generations, or how ink dropped into water appears to "flow"). Instead of explaining the patterns of these processes as emerging from the collective interactions of all the agents (e.g., both the water and the ink molecules), students often explain the pattern as being caused by controlling agents with intentional goals, as well as express a variety of many other misconceived notions. In this article, we provide a hypothesis for what constitutes a misconceived explanation; why misconceived explanations are so prevalent, robust, and resistant to instruction; and offer one approach of how they may be overcome. In particular, we hypothesize that students misunderstand many science processes because they rely on a generalized version of narrative schemas and scripts (referred to here as a Direct-causal Schema) to interpret them. For science processes that are sequential and stage-like, such as cycles of moon, circulation of blood, stages of mitosis, and photosynthesis, a Direct-causal Schema is adequate for correct understanding. However, for science processes that are non-sequential (or emergent), such as diffusion, natural selection, osmosis, and heat flow, using a Direct Schema to understand these processes will lead to robust misconceptions. Instead, a different type of general schema may be required to interpret non-sequential processes, which we refer to as an Emergent-causal Schema. We propose that students lack this Emergent Schema and teaching it to them may help them learn and understand emergent kinds of science processes such as diffusion. Our study found that directly teaching students this Emergent Schema led to increased learning of the process of diffusion. This article presents a fine-grained characterization of each type of Schema, our instructional intervention, the successes we have achieved, and the lessons we have learned.


PMID: 22050726

DOI: 10.1111/j.1551-6709.2011.01207.x

Other references

Barac, B., 1974: Retrospective view on the development of clinical neurophysiology in Croatia. Neuropsihijatrija 22(1-4): 163-168

Browner, W.S., 1986: Preventable complications of diabetes mellitus. Western Journal of Medicine 145(5): 701-703

Jin, Dao-chao., 1994: Four new species of the genus Hygrobates and redescription of Hygrobates sinensis Uchida and Imamura from China (Acari: Hygrobatidae). Acta Zootaxonomica Sinica. Jan; 191: 67-74

Patterson S.; Macnaughton M.R., 1981: Distribution of human coronavirus strain 229e on the surface of human di ploid cells. The distribution of human coronavirus strain 229E (HCV 229E) particles on the surface of human diploid (MRCc) cells was examined. Virus particles showed a totally random distribution on fixed cells and on cells to which virus had been adsorbed in...

Hilal, A.R.; Hilal, R., 2017: Photodissociation of FONO: an excited state nonadiabatic dynamics study. The photo dissociation of nitrosyl fluorite, FONO, a potential source of atmospheric fluorine, underlies its active role in ozone depletion and other activities in the troposphere. In the present work, the electronic structure of FONO is revisited...

Sarup, P.; Panwar, V.P.S.; Marwaha, K.K.; Siddiqui, K.H., 1978: Management of maize pests with particular reference to the stalk borer, Chilo partellus (Swinhoe) under resource constraints. Field-plot tests were carried out in India in 1974 on the effect of early (20 June) and normal (5 July) sowings of the maize varieties Vijay composite and Basi local and treatment with nitrogen fertilizer at 50 and 100 kg nitrogen/ha on damage cau...

Kohler, B.W.lle, H., 1980: Bakteriologische Untersuchungen bei abortierten Schweinefeten unter besonderer Berucksichtigung der atiologischen Bedeutung von Staphylococcus aureus. Monatshefte fur Veterinarmedizin, 35(13): 506-510

Baumann, U.; Mansouri, E.; von Specht, B-U., 2004: Recombinant OprF-OprI as a vaccine against Pseudomonas aeruginosa infections. A vaccine against Pseudomonas aeruginosa based on recombinant outer membranes has been developed. After intramuscularly injecting into patients with severe burns, antibodies against P. aeruginosa were induced. Vaccination was well tolerated. Intra...

Sokoloff P.A., 1978: A note on rearing ptycholomoides aeriferanus lepidoptera tortricidae. Entomologist'S Record & Journal Of Variation: 10

Slama G., 1984: Clinical research in diabetology new criteria treatments and approaches. Papoz, L (Ed ) Colloque Inserm (Institut National De La Sante Et De La Recherche Medicale), Vol 122 Methodologie Des Etudes Epidemiologiques Et Cliniques Sur Le Diabete (National Institute Of Health And Medical Research Colloquium, Vol 122 The Methodology Of Epidemiological And Clinical Studies on Diabetes); Meeting, Paris, France, Oct 1-5, 261p Editions Inserm: Paris, France Illus Paper 157-170