geoscience.net logo
+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

The double-edged sword: does biomechanism increase or decrease judges' sentencing of psychopaths?


, : The double-edged sword: does biomechanism increase or decrease judges' sentencing of psychopaths?. Science 337(6096): 846-849

We tested whether expert testimony concerning a biomechanism of psychopathy increases or decreases punishment. In a nationwide experiment, U.S. state trial judges (N = 181) read a hypothetical case (based on an actual case) where the convict was diagnosed with psychopathy. Evidence presented at sentencing in support of a biomechanical cause of the convict's psychopathy significantly reduced the extent to which psychopathy was rated as aggravating and significantly reduced sentencing (from 13.93 years to 12.83 years). Content analysis of judges' reasoning indicated that even though the majority of judges listed aggravating factors (86.7%), the biomechanical evidence increased the proportion of judges listing mitigating factors (from 29.7 to 47.8%). Our results contribute to the literature on how biological explanations of behavior figure into theories of culpability and punishment.

US$19.90

PMID: 22904010

DOI: 10.1126/science.1219569


Other references

Ruiz, E.; Madrigal Bujaidar, E.; Salazar, M.; Carvajal, G.; Chamorro, G., 1999: Clastogenic activity of the new anticonvulsant 4-hydroxy-4-ethyl-4-phenylbutyramide in a Tradescantia bioassay. The compound 4-hydroxy-4-ethyl-4-phenylbutyramide (HEPB) is a cyclic hydroxylamide chemical recently synthesized as part of a series of phenyl alcohol amides with anticonvulsant activity. Experimental studies have shown that HEPB protects rats and...

Katahira, Y.; Nitta, S.; Tanaka, M.; Hongo, T.; Kagawa, Y., 1986: Quantitative analysis of the flow in the artificial heart by the tracer method. The tracer method was utilized for the quantitative analysis of the flow field within artificial heart (AH) using mock circulatory loop. The flow behavior was analyzed with a numerical method. The length and location of the particle paths on the f...

Kuo Shiou San; Stangland Herbert G., 1986: Use of ground penetrating radar techniques to aid in the design of on-site disposal systems. Pages 502-525 1986

Schulze P J.; Czok G., 1973: Inefficacy of tauro cholate in bromsulfophthalein induced cholestasis in bile salt depleted rats. Digestion 8(6): 548-549

Odone, P.; Alessio, L., 1979: Current views on permissible levels of occupational exposure to inorganic lead. La Medicina del Lavoro 70(1): 3-7

Khokhar, N., 1979: Right hilar mass and hemoptysis. Hospital Practice 14(5): 88, 90, 94-88, 90, 94

Karlman, M.; Van Der Kamp, B.; Witzell, J., 1995: The susceptibility of Scots pine to the pathogens of lodgepole pine. Kaneko, S [Editor], Katsuya, K [Editor], Kashishima, M [Editor], Ono, Y [Editor] Proceedings of the Fourth IUFRO Rusts of Pines Working Party Conference 135-138

Tichy, H., 1987: Fruhlings- Punktmonitoring der Vogel bei Louny. Sbornik Severoceskeho Muzea Prirodni Vedy Scientiae Naturales, 16: 199-207

Savitskii, V.I., 1963: Preoperative preparation of patients with mitral stenosis. Zdravookhranenie Belorussii 9: 16-18

El-Atem, N.; Irvine, K.M.; Valery, P.C.; Wojcik, K.; Horsfall, L.; Johnson, T.; Janda, M.; McPhail, S.M.; Powell, E.E., 2016: Identifying areas of need relative to liver disease: geographic clustering within a health service district. NlmCategory="UNASSIGNED"><b>Background</b> Many people with chronic liver disease (CLD) are not detected until they present to hospital with advanced disease, when opportunities for intervention are reduced and morbidity i...