+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Colonoscopy evaluations: justification by cost?

, : Colonoscopy evaluations: justification by cost?. American Journal of Gastroenterology 91(3): 614-615

The type of colonic imaging (radiological vs colonoscopic) for evaluating symptomatic patients without evidence of bleeding in both an efficacious and cost-conserving manner has become a very debated issue. In a randomized, controlled clinical trial, the authors hoped to examine the prevalence of neoplasm and the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of initial diagnostic strategies of colonoscopy versus flexible sigmoidoscopy and air contrast barium enema in patients without evidence of intestinal bleeding. One hundred forty-nine patients over the age of 40 with symptoms suggestive a colonic disease without evidence of bleeding (no hematechezia, negative test for fecal occult blood, and normal serum hemoglobin) were randomized to undergo either initial colonoscopy or flexible sigmoidoscopy plus barium enema. Patients with incomplete lower GI tests were referred for the corresponding alternative imaging modality. Cost analyses using sensitivity analysis were performed. Baseline information with respect to age, race, sex, inpatient status, reason for referral, mean weight loss, hemoglobin, blood urea nitrogen, and albumin were similar in both groups. Eighteen patients (24%) who initially received air contrast barium enema and flexible sigmoidoscopy then required colonoscopy, whereas only five patients (6%) who initially underwent colonoscopy first required air contrast barium enema plus flexible sigmoidoscopy. The study found that: a) The prevalence of cancer in the study was low (one of 149 patients); b) initial colonoscopy detected more persons with adenomas than that of air contrast barium enema plus flexible sigmoidoscopy (23 of 75 patients vs 13 of 74 patients, odds radio, 2.07, CI,0.90-4.92; this approached significance); and c) air contrast barium enema plus flexible sigmoidoscopy detected more diverticulosis (46 of 74 patients vs 31 of 75 patients, odds ratio, 0.41, 95% CI, 0.21-0.87). The significant conclusions were that patients undergoing flexible sigmoidoscopy plus air contrast barium enema were more likely to undergo alternative procedures and that sensitivity analysis suggested that, for most areas in the United States, initial colonoscopy would be more cost-effective for the outcome of detection of adenomas (1).


PMID: 8633528

Other references

Dreyfuss, R., 1961: Apropos of the abuse of certain drugs. Praxis 50: 1093-1094

Perruchoud A.; Kopp C.; Herzog H., 1977: Shock lung clinical aspects and treatment. Intensivmedizin 14(4): 274-283

Sincak, C.A.; Schmidt, J.M., 2009: Iclaprim, a novel diaminopyrimidine for the treatment of resistant gram-positive infections. To review the pharmacology, microbiology, in vitro susceptibility, pharmacokinetics, clinical trial data, safety, and tolerability of iclaprim, a novel dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) inhibitor. A MEDLINE search was conducted from 1966 through Dece...

Sutherland, I.A.; Brown, A.E.; Green, R.S.; Miller, C.M.; Leathwick, D.M., 1999: The immune response of sheep to larval challenge with Ostertagia circumcincta and O. ostertagi. One of three groups of sheep was challenged twice-weekly with infective-stage larvae (L3) of the sheep parasite O. circumcincta, another with the cattle parasite O. ostertagi while the third received no larval challenge. Positive faecal egg counts...

Savitsky, N.; Rangell, L., 1948: Homonymous hemianopsis in multiple sclerosis. In a recent resume of the clinical features of multiple sclerosis it was stated that hemi-anopsia occurs but is uncommon. Brief mention is made of previous reports and the disagreement in conclusions is stressed. The present report is based on 416...

Ottosen, C.O.; Mortensen, L.M.; Gislerod, H.R., 2002: Effect of relative air humidity on gas exchange, stomatal conductance and nutrient uptake in miniature potted roses. The study was conducted to evaluate the effect of relative air humidity (RH) and Ca/K ratio on the physiological reactions of potted miniature roses cv. Parade Fiesta. The plants were grown at constant temperature and three RH levels (70, 80 and 9...

Mattingly P.F., 1981: The subgenera rachionotomyia tricholeptomyia and tripteroides mabinii group of genus tripteroides in the oriental region diptera culicidae. Subgenus Rachionotomyia is redescribed and 5 spp. currently included in Tripteroides s.s. are transferred to it. Tricholeptomyia is resurrected from synonymy as a valid subgenus. One species is transferred to it from Rachionotomyia. It includes al...

Kail, R., 1992: General slowing of information-processing by persons with mental retardation. On measures of speeded performance, persons with mental retardation typically respond more slowly than do those without mental retardation. A review of 45 published studies yielded 518 pairs of response times (RTs) in which each pair consisted of...

Jang, Y.Han.; Seong, B.Lin., 2015: Options and obstacles for designing a universal influenza vaccine. Since the discovery of antibodies specific to a highly conserved stalk region of the influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA), eliciting such antibodies has been considered the key to developing a universal influenza vaccine that confers broad-spectrum...

Ryss E.S.; Fishzon Ryss Y.I., 1991: Nonulcerative dyspepsia conceptual clinical diagnostic and therapeutic aspects. Klinicheskaya Meditsina (Moscow) 69(4): 105-108