+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Identifying poor-quality hospitals. Can hospital mortality rates detect quality problems for medical diagnoses?

, : Identifying poor-quality hospitals. Can hospital mortality rates detect quality problems for medical diagnoses?. Medical Care 34(8): 737-753

Many groups involved in health care are very interested in using external quality indices, such as risk-adjusted mortality rates, to examine hospital quality. The authors evaluated the feasibility of using mortality rates for medical diagnoses to identify poor-quality hospitals. The Monte Carlo simulation model was used to examine whether mortality rates could distinguish 172 average-quality hospitals from 19 poor-quality hospitals (5% versus 25% of deaths being preventable, respectively), using the largest diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) for cardiac, gastrointestinal, cerebrovascular, and pulmonary diseases as well as an aggregate of all medical DRGs. Discharge counts and observed death rates for all 191 Michigan hospitals were obtained from the Michigan Inpatient Database. Positive predictive value (PPV), sensitivity, and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve were calculated for mortality outlier status as an indicator of poor-quality hospitals. Sensitivity analysis was performed under varying assumptions about the time period of evaluation, quality differences between hospitals, and unmeasured variability in hospital casemix. For individual DRG groups, mortality rates were a poor measure of quality, even using the optimistic assumption of perfect casemix adjustment. For acute myocardial infarction, high mortality rate outlier status (using 2 years of data and a 0.05 probability cutoff) had a PPV of only 24%, thus, more than three fourths of those labeled poor-quality hospitals (high mortality rate outliers) actually would have average quality. If we aggregate all medical DRGs and continue to assume very large quality differences and perfect casemix adjustment, the sensitivity for detecting poor-quality hospitals is 35% and PPV is 52%. Even for this extreme case, the PPV is very sensitive to introduction of small amounts of unmeasured casemix differences between hospitals. Although they may be useful for some surgical diagnoses, DRG-specific hospital mortality rates probably cannot accurately detect poor-quality outliers for medical diagnoses. Even collapsing to all medical DRGs, hospital mortality rates seem unlikely to be accurate predictors of poor quality, and punitive measures based on high mortality rates frequently would penalize good or average hospitals.


PMID: 8709656

Other references

Wareing, PF.; Graham, CF., 1984: Nucleus and cytoplasm. Unknown

Ieniştea, O., 1978: Treatment of disorders of sexual dynamics in students. Revista de Medicina Interna, Neurologie, Psihiatrie, Neurochirurgie, Dermato-Venerologie. Neurologie, Psihiatrie, Neurochirurgie 23(2): 135-140

Fritz, K.; Sowig, P., 1988: Verbreitung, Habitatanspruche und Gefahrdung der Zauneidechse (Lacerta agilis Linnaeus, 1758) in Baden-Wurttemberg. Mertensiella, 205-214 No. 1

den Besten, PJ.; Maas, JR.; Livingstone, DR.; Zandee, DI.; Voogt, PA., 1991: Interference of benzopyrene with cytochrome P-450-mediated steroid metabolism in pyloric caeca microsomes of the sea star Asterias rubens L. 1.1. The effects of benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) on the metabolism of progesterone and pregnenolone, and the effects of steroids on BaP metabolism were examined in pyloric caeca microsomes of female Asterias rubens.2.2. The patterns of metabolism of proge...

Marczynski G.; Dingwall A.; Shapiro L., 1990: Plasmid and chromosomal replication and partitioning during the caulobacter crescentus cell cycle. Abstracts of the Annual Meeting of the American Society for Microbiology 90: 172

Jakovljević, M., 2006: The modern psychopharmacotherapy, mind-body medicine and science of well-being. Body, brain, mind & spirit: all for one, and one for all. Psychiatria Danubina 18(3-4): 148-149

Espelage, D.L.; Cauffman, E.; Broidy, L.; Piquero, A.R.; Mazerolle, P.; Steiner, H., 2003: A cluster-analytic investigation of MMPI profiles of serious male and female juvenile offenders. Objective: To use cluster analysis to identify psychological profiles and related mental health symptoms among male and female juvenile offenders. Method: Juvenile offenders (N = 141) incarcerated in the California Youth Authority completed the Mi...

He, S.C.; Lin, D.F.; Zhang, K.G.; Xue, L., 1983: On biological speciality of asexual reproduction of wheat powdery mildew. Conidia of Erysiphe graminis germinated at -2 degrees to 34 degrees C (opt. 10-17 degrees ). Detached conidia retained infectivity for 5 days at 2 degrees , 3 days at 7-17 degrees and 2 days at 20 degrees . Although conidia could germinate at RH 0...

Subbotin, V.M.; Subbotin, M.Ia.; Kolesnikov, S.I.; Paraskun, V.G., 1976: Human placental morphology as an index of features of maternal-fetal relationships. Principle possibilities of the complex evaluation of the mother-fetus exchange were studied by means of morphological investigations of the human placenta in normality, in vesicular mole, late toxicoses, hemolytic disease of newborns and malformat...

Xiao, R.; Perveen, Z.; Paulsen, D.; Rouse, R.; Ambalavanan, N.; Kearney, M.; Penn, A.L., 2013: In utero exposure to second-hand smoke aggravates adult responses to irritants: adult second-hand smoke. In utero exposure to second-hand smoke (SHS) is associated with exacerbated asthmatic responses in children. We tested the hypothesis that in utero SHS will aggravate the lung responses of young adult mice re-exposed to SHS. We exposed Balb/c mice...