+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

The importance of theory: response to Brenner (2000)

, : The importance of theory: response to Brenner (2000). Psychological Review 107(4): 947-949

L. Brenner's (2000) critique of I. Erev, T. S. Wallsten and D. V. Budescu (1994) focuses on their (a) use of a model to explain the paradox of the same data appearing to suggest over- and underconfidence, depending on how they are analyzed; (b) definitions of true judgment and error; and (c) specific use of judgments transformed to log-odds and a model formulated in those terms. The authors of the present article strongly disagree with the first point and discuss the importance of using models to interpret data. With regard to the second, the authors admit that the constructs of true judgment and error are poorly named but dispute L. Brenner's specific criticisms. Concerning the third, the authors had not claimed that the log-odds metric has any special status in judgment research and thus agree with L. Brenner's basic point.


PMID: 11089413

Other references

Vuilleumier, Philippe., 1992: Un grand butor echappe de peu a un renard. Nos Oiseaux. Decembre; 418: 489

L.Bail, B., 2012: Pathology: a pictorial review. A selected atlas of paediatric liver pathology. Indications for liver biopsy in children are often specific to this age group, especially in young children for the diagnosis of cholestasis. Since liver biopsies are quite unfrequent in the children population and concern rare but various disease...

Sheridan, P.; Kinkle, B.K., 1996: Isolation, characterization, and 16S rRNA-based phylogenetic analysis of an Antarctic cryptoendolithic cyanobacterium. Abstracts of the General Meeting of the American Society for Microbiology 96(0): 343

Hotta, H.; Fukushima, S., 1970: Fishing ground of Sawry and its oceanographic conditions in the Pacific Ocean off Northeastern Japan. Bull. Jap. Soc. scient. Fish.: 36: 207-214

Auletta M.; Gange R.W.; Tan O.T.; Matzinger E., 1986: Effect of cutaneous hypoxia upon erythema and pigment responses of uv a uv b and 8 methoxypsoralen plus uv a in human skin. The effect of oxygen deprivation upon UVA-, UVB-, and PUVA-induced pigment and erythema responses in normal human skin was examined. Before exposure, varying degrees of hypoxia in the skin of the forearm were achieved by inflating a sphygmomanomet...

Fujak, A.; Kopschina, C.; Gras, F.; Forst, R.; Forst, Jürgen., 2011: Contractures of the lower extremities in spinal muscular atrophy type II. Descriptive clinical study with retrospective data collection. Early development of contractures and progressive scoliosis with pelvic obliquity are the most significant orthopaedic problems for children with the intermediate form of spinal muscular atrophy, SMA type II. This study deals with the restrictions...

Götzel, L., 1976: Congenital multicystic renal dysplasia in the adult age. In the multicystical renal dysplasia we have to do with a congenital malformation due to a developmental disturbance of the bud of the ureter. It is characterized by a conglomerate of cysts, rarely by a single cyst without a functioning renal pare...

Krumbein, A.; Ulrich, D., 2003: Assessment of flavour volatiles in vegetables - from comprehensive to rapid methods. A mass spectrometric sensor was tested for discrimination of six tomato cultivars (Vanessa, Rubor, Panovy, Minni, Piccolino and Campari) and was compared with GC-MS using complete separation of volatiles. Variance analysis of aroma volatiles obtai...

Hou, J.K.; Abudayyeh, S.; Shaib, Y., 2011: Treatment of chronic radiation proctitis with cryoablation. Chronic radiation proctitis (CRP) is a common problem in patients receiving pelvic radiation. Current therapies have the potential for deep tissue injury with ulcerations, perforation, and fistula formation. Cryospray ablation therapy offers super...

Terradillos, J.; López-Goñi, J.J.; Olleta, A.Arteaga., 2012: Evaluation of results of a program of Responsible Alcoholic Beverage Dispensing. Selective prevention programs in the Responsible Dispensing of Beverages (DRA - Dispensación Responsable de Bebidas Alcohólicas) have provided varying evidence of their effectiveness in other countries. In Spain, however, data is only available...