geoscience.net logo
+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

A case report: ethics of a proposed qualitative study of hospital closure in an Australian rural community


, : A case report: ethics of a proposed qualitative study of hospital closure in an Australian rural community. Family Practice 21(1): 87-91

The GP and qualitative researcher use similar patient-centred approaches, but their roles are different. Guidelines for conducting GP research in small communities are limited. I planned a qualitative study about hospital closure in a small rural Australian town where I worked. Few studies have researched community reaction to hospital closure and this process of change. I used historical analysis to improve external reliability, and purposeful sampling to develop and pre-test a qualitative semi-structured research instrument. Newspaper articles, minutes and tape recordings of public meetings, annual reports from 1991 to 1997, quality assurance data and interviews with two health professionals were analysed in this process. These sources were coded using content and thematic analysis. Ethical issues arose during early stages of planning. Ethical guidelines and bioethics principles were discussed with colleagues and a member of an ethics committee. I validated my findings with three other community members involved in the hospital closure. Themes of a transition, from resistance to change and divisions between key stake holders, to a need to appreciate the benefits of change emerged in coding material from 1991 to 1997. The principle of non-maleficence outweighed the principle of beneficence in this study. Existing health services could be harmed by examining the process of change after spending time and resources to reconcile community differences. Individuals could be harmed as confidentiality in a small community was difficult to maintain, and discussions about sensitive issues could produce adverse public criticism. The autonomy of participants to give informed consent was complicated by the author providing clinical services in the community, raising concerns about patients feeling an obligation to participate. A justified case for discontinuing this study was made by the researcher on ethical grounds. Use of bioethical principles and community representatives to validate findings was a useful technique to guide decisions in a small rural community. This discussion has application in planning other small community studies.

US$29.90

PMID: 14760052


Other references

Taylor A.G.; Kenny T.J., 1985: Improvement of germinated seed quality by density separation. Germinated seeds of 'King Cole' cabbage (Brassica oleracea L. capitata) were separated on a float-sink basis from nongerminated seeds by density differences. Aqueous solutions of varying densities were prepared from Maltrin 250. Brief ex...

Huang, C.; Wylie, B.; Yang, L.; Homer, C.; Zylstra, G., 2002: Derivation of a tasselled cap transformation based on Landsat 7 at-satellite reflectance. An at-satellite reflectance based taselled cap transformation was developed based on 10 Landsat 7 Enhanced Thematic Mapper Plus scenes representing a variety of landscapes of the USA in both leaf-on and leaf-off seasons. This transformation is mos...

Baltaci, A.K.; Mogulkoc, R.; Bediz, C.S.; Kul, A.; Ugur, A., 2003: Pinealectomy and zinc deficiency have opposite effects on thyroid hormones in rats. The present study was conducted to investigate how pinealectomy and zinc deficiency separately or in combination affected thyroid hormones in rats. The study was carried out on 40 Sprague-Dawley male rats. The rats were equally allocated to four g...

Bickel, J., 1997: Gender stereotypes and misconceptions: unresolved issues in physicians' professional development. JAMA 277(17): 1405, 1407-1405, 1407

Dong, Y.; Wang, Y-Zheng., 2015: Seed shattering: from models to crops. Seed shattering (or pod dehiscence, or fruit shedding) is essential for the propagation of their offspring in wild plants but is a major cause of yield loss in crops. In the dicot model species, Arabidopsis thaliana, pod dehiscence necessitates a...

Ganor, Eliezer, 1999: A method for identifying sulfuric acid in single cloud and fog droplets. We describe herein a novel method for identifying sulfuric acid in single droplets of mist, fog or cloud. The method is based on a microchemical reaction displayed by the droplets upon a shiny cleavage plane (1 0 1 1) of Iceland spar - the rhomboh...

Collins S.; Kanamarlapudi L.; Bermes E.W.; Brooks M.H., 1987: Determination of free thyroxine levels by combining ultrafiltration with ria. Clinical Chemistry 33(6): 884

Pezoldt, J.; Huehn, J., 2016: Tissue-Specific Induction of CCR6 and Nrp1 During Early CD4 + T Cell Differentiation. NlmCategory="UNASSIGNED">Upon differentiation, T cells acquire tissue-specific homing properties allowing efficient targeting of effector T cells into distinct inflamed organs. Priming of T cells within skin-draining, peripheral lymph...

Mordasini R.; Oetliker O.; Lutschg J.; Greten H., 1978: Disturbed lipid metabolism in patients with nephrosis. European Journal of Clinical Investigation 8(5): 346

Fernandez Labriola, Roberto S., 1963: Fifteen cases treated with 53-11 C. Diethyl-amonio-ethoxy (carbonyl)-3-pyri-dine citrate was used in 10 cases of physical fatigue and 5 cases of neurasthenic fatigue and found helpful in the former but not in the latter.