+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Admirable dishonesty in medical practice

, : Admirable dishonesty in medical practice. Communication & Medicine 10(1): 27-35

Historically, the ethics of dishonesty within the physician-patient relationship has been analyzed largely from the deontological and consequentialist viewpoints. In this essay I offer a new exploration of dishonesty from the recently developed Virtue Ethics of Care perspective. First, I will explain and justify a general prescription for honest conduct within the relationship. Next, I will explore the conditions under which the Virtue Ethics of Care would find acts of dishonesty in medical practice to be admirable. Here, the moral distinction between lying and deception will be discussed. Then, two special contexts in medical practice, paternalistic dishonesty and patient dishonesty, will be analyzed. I will close with a discussion of the role of trust in the relationship and how it acts to prevent the Virtue Ethics of Care from sliding down the path toward objectionable acts of dishonesty.


PMID: 24851515

Other references

Kende H.; Raskin I., 1984: On the regulation of growth in deep water rice. Plant Physiology (Rockville) 75(SUPPL 1): 184

Darke, S.G., 1992: The morphology of recurrent varicose veins. Over an 18-month period, of 444 patients referred for treatment for varicose veins, 95 (21%) had had previous surgery. By means of clinical hand-held Doppler and in selected venographic evaluation these were subdivided into three groups as follows...

Rossouw, Gideon., 1993: Palaeontology in South Africa - its origin. Naturalist (Port Elizabeth). March; 371: 31-33

Motley, H.L.; Cournand, A., 2011: Intravascular and intracardiac pressure recording in man; electrical apparatus compared with the Hamilton manometer. Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine. Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine 64(2): 241-244

Otsuka, S.; Ichii, O.; Namiki, Y.; Sasaki, N.; Hashimoto, Y.; Kon, Y., 2013: Genomic analysis of the appearance of testicular oocytes in MRL/MpJ mice. Mammals produce sperm or oocytes depending on their sex; however, newborn MRL/MpJ (MRL) male mice produce oocytes within their testes. We previously reported that one of the genes responsible for this phenotype is present on the MRL-type Y chromos...

Gigliotti B.; Moretti G.F.; Urru G.; Multinu A.; Rosa M.F.; Cossu G.; Pirastru M.G.; Serra M.; Budroni M., 1991: Cytogenetic amniocentesis during the second term of pregnancy an analysis of 850 cases. International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics (ABSTR SUPPL): 56

Fedorova Z.F., 1977: Influence of spheroplast formation and subsequent reversions on the virulence and other biological indices of escherichia coli o 124 k 72 b 17. Zhurnal Mikrobiologii Epidemiologii i Immunobiologii 8: 7-11

Kunwar, G.S.; Deo, P.G., 1967: Studies on the acquired resistance of sheep to Dictyocaulus filaria (Rudolphi, 1809) Railliet and Henry, 1907. Thirty housed, helminth-free lambs were given a primary infection of 500 to 5, 000 Dictyocaulus filaria larvae followed by a challenge infection of 5, 000 larvae 24 to 51 days later. Worm counts on autopsy showed that in 2 lambs the primary infect...

Fisher, E., 1977: A new use for the planting board. North American pomona: er 10 (1) 26-27

Mcgrew,. Jr.;, 1970: Strawberry feather-leaf. Virus diseases of small fruits and grapevines: 6-47