+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Autonomy, evidence and intuition: nurses and decision-making

, : Autonomy, evidence and intuition: nurses and decision-making. Journal of Advanced Nursing 66(7): 1584-1591

This paper is a report of a study conducted to examine how nurses represent professional clinical decision-making processes, and to determine what light Jamous and Peloille's 'Indeterminacy/Technicality ratio' concept can shed on these representations. Classic definitions of professional work feature autonomy of decision-making and control over the field of work. Sociologists Jamous and Peloille have described professional work as being high in 'indeterminacy' (the use of tacit judgements) relative to technicality (activity able to be codified). The rise of the evidence-based practice movement has been seen as increasing the realm of technical decision-making in healthcare, and it is relevant to analyse nurses' professional discourse and study how they respond to this increase. Three focus groups with qualified nurses attending post-qualifying courses at a London university were held in 2008. Participants were asked to talk about influences on their decision-making. The discussions were tape-recorded, transcribed and subjected to discourse analysis. Participants described their decision-making as influenced by both indeterminate and technical features. They acknowledged useful influences from both domains, but pointed to their personal 'experience' as the final arbiter of decision-making. Their accounts of decision-making created a sense of professional autonomy while at the same time protecting it against external critique. Pre- and post-registration nurse education could encourage robust discussion of the definition and roles of 'irrational' aspects of decision-making and how these might be understood as components of credible professional practice.


PMID: 20497271

DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2010.05317.x

Other references

Mazur, T.; Mackowiak, C.; Koc, J., 1984: Comparison of effectiveness of animal slurry nitrogen and commercial fertilizer nitrogen i. influence on yield and chemical composition of potato tubers and residual effect on spring barley. Over the period 1976-1979 a field experiment was conducted on the soil of a good rye complex, to compare the effectiveness of swine slurry nitrogen with that of commercial fertilizer nitrogen. The slurry was applied in autumn or in spring. The pho...

Finley, D.A.; Lönnerdal, B.; Dewey, K.G.; Grivetti, L.E., 1985: Inorganic constituents of breast milk from vegetarian and nonvegetarian women: relationships with each other and with organic constituents. Changes in concentrations of minerals, trace elements, protein, lactose and total lipids during 20 mo of lactation and correlations between levels of these milk constituents were studied in a carefully defined set of 222 milk samples collected fro...

Parfrey P.S.; Lee C.R.; Markandu N.D.; Roulston J.E.; Squires M.; Macgregor G.A., 1981: Relationship between arterial blood pressure and dietary sodium intake in subjects with and without a familial predisposition to hypertension. Clinical Science (London) 61(3): 30P

Fitzpatrick, J.M.; Blackledge, G.; Newling, D., 2002: PSA: Promoter of stress and anxiety or providentially-sent antigen?. Measurement of serum prostate-specific antigen (PSA) levels has revolutionised all aspects of the management of men with prostate cancer. As well as monitoring established disease, PSA testing has an important role in the early detection of prosta...

Lacroix Alfred, 1940: Les roches depourvues de feldspath du cortege des sakenites Madagascar; composition chimique de cet ensemble. Describes the aluminum-magnesium rocks low in feldspar content associated with the sakenites of Madagascar. They include saphirinites, spinellites, pyroxenites with saphirine and spinel, and a saphirine amphibolite. Chemical analyses are given.

Matsuda, Hideaki, 1999: Study on efficacy of processed Ginseng, Red Ginseng. Ginseng Radix is an indispensable herb medicine in traditional Chinese medicine and has long been used as a tonic of characteristic sort for treatment of miscellaneous diseases. It is clinically used popularly in the domain of Kampo medicine in Ja...

Peters, I.I., 1966: Soft and semi-soft ripened Dalton cheese. Dalton cheese is defined as a ripened cheese made from calculated mixes that do not yield whey as a by-product. The soft variety was made from cream, dried skim-milk, stabilizer, sodium polyphosphate, HC1, colour, starter and rennet. It contained...

Austin R.T.; England A.W., 1991: Surface characterization of volcanic debris flows at multiple scales. International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium 11: 1675-1678

Endres, H., 1895: Anstichversuche an Eiern von Rana fusca Zweiter Theil Erganzung durch Anstichversuche an Eiern von Rana esculenta Bowie theoretische Folgerungen aus beiden Versuchsreihen. Archiv fuer Entwicklungsmechanik, II 517-543

Hartman, D.J.; Hoogenraad, N.J.; Condron, R.; Høj, P.B., 1992: Identification of a mammalian 10-kDa heat shock protein, a mitochondrial chaperonin 10 homologue essential for assisted folding of trimeric ornithine transcarbamoylase in vitro. We have identified a 10-kDa stress-inducible mitochondrial protein. The protein is synthesized at elevated rates in cultured rat hepatoma cells challenged with heat shock or amino acid analogues and, therefore, designated heat shock protein 10 (Hs...