geoscience.net logo
+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Does consideration of larger study areas yield more accurate estimates of air pollution health effects? An illustration of the bias-variance trade-off in air pollution epidemiology


, : Does consideration of larger study areas yield more accurate estimates of air pollution health effects? An illustration of the bias-variance trade-off in air pollution epidemiology. Environment International 60(): 23-30

Spatially-resolved air pollution models can be developed in large areas. The resulting increased exposure contrasts and population size offer opportunities to better characterize the effect of atmospheric pollutants on respiratory health. However the heterogeneity of these areas may also enhance the potential for confounding. We aimed to discuss some analytical approaches to handle this trade-off. We modeled NO2 and PM10 concentrations at the home addresses of 1082 pregnant mothers from EDEN cohort living in and around urban areas, using ADMS dispersion model. Simulations were performed to identify the best strategy to limit confounding by unmeasured factors varying with area type. We examined the relation between modeled concentrations and respiratory health in infants using regression models with and without adjustment or interaction terms with area type. Simulations indicated that adjustment for area limited the bias due to unmeasured confounders varying with area at the costs of a slight decrease in statistical power. In our cohort, rural and urban areas differed for air pollution levels and for many factors associated with respiratory health and exposure. Area tended to modify effect measures of air pollution on respiratory health. Increasing the size of the study area also increases the potential for residual confounding. Our simulations suggest that adjusting for type of area is a good option to limit residual confounding due to area-associated factors without restricting the area size. Other statistical approaches developed in the field of spatial epidemiology are an alternative to control for poorly-measured spatially-varying confounders.

US$19.90

PMID: 23994839

DOI: 10.1016/j.envint.2013.07.005


Other references

Jacobson, M.K.; Clench, W.J., 1971: On some Helicina from the Dominican Republic. Nautilus Philad, 84: 101-107

Wallis, D.J.; Hetherington, M.M., 2009: Emotions and eating. Self-reported and experimentally induced changes in food intake under stress. Two studies investigated the stress-eating relationship. The first examined self-reported changes in intake of snack foods, whilst the second investigated stress-induced overconsumption in a laboratory setting comparing high (HF) and low-fat (LF)...

Ozturk, S.; Kaseko, G.; Mahaworasilpa, T.; Coster, H.G.L., 2003: Adaptation of cell lines to serum-free culture medium. The optimum conditions to allow proliferation of cells for the secretion of some growth factors and cytokines and the proliferation of cells in different media that do not contain proteins or serum from animals (serum-free media) were investigated...

Valenzuela, P.; Romero, R., 1982: Creep in amalgams with high copper content. Odontologia Chilena 30(128): 81-84

Nguyen, H.T.; Passerotti, C.C.; Penna, F.J.; Retik, A.B.; Peters, C.A., 2009: Robotic assisted laparoscopic Mitrofanoff appendicovesicostomy: preliminary experience in a pediatric population. Continent urinary diversion has a central role in treating various urinary tract conditions and traditionally has been performed as an open procedure. We report on 10 patients who underwent a robotic assisted laparoscopic Mitrofanoff procedure usi...

Ryan Pete; Thompson Gray, 1991: Structural and compositional variations in low-grade metamorphic illite and chlorite from the Belt Supergroup, Montana and Idaho. Program and Abstracts - Annual Clay Minerals Conference 28: 134

Franco, H.; Silva, R., 1971: Weed control in tobacco. In trials with tobacco cv. Colombiana 37 in the Cauca Valley the effect of 20 herbicides applied pre-em., mechanical row-cleaning or no weeding, were investigated. Maximum yields were 2.146, 2.097 and 2.042 t/ha from mechanical weeding, 4 kg nitro...

Ali, H.A.; Osman, R.R.; Idris, M.N.; Sokrab, T-Eldin.O., 2007: Anticardiolipin antibodies in stroke patients in Sudan. Appraisal of their significance in a region of high burden of endemic infections. To screen and evaluate the significance of anticardiolipin seroprevalence in patients with acute ischemic stroke, in patients with infectious disease, and in healthy subjects resident in Sudan, a tropical country endemic for several infectious dis...

Son'kin, V.D., 1988: Development of energy support for muscle activity in adolescents. Fiziologiia Cheloveka 14(2): 248-255

Nidzieko, Nicholas J., 2010: Tidal asymmetry in estuaries with mixed semidiurnal/diurnal tides. Tidal asymmetry in estuaries with mixed, mainly semidiurnal tides arises from both the interaction of principal tides and the higher harmonics generated by distortions within the estuary. The duration asymmetry in rise and fall of water level caus...