geoscience.net logo
+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Evidence of dissociative amnesia in science and literature: culture-bound approaches to trauma in Pope, Poliakoff, Parker, Boynes, and Hudson (2007)


, : Evidence of dissociative amnesia in science and literature: culture-bound approaches to trauma in Pope, Poliakoff, Parker, Boynes, and Hudson (2007). Journal of Trauma & Dissociation 10(3): 237-53; Discussion 254-60

The current culture of traumatic stress studies includes research that identifies the ways in which stress and trauma impair learning and memory in both humans and animals. Yet it also contains health professionals who argue that individuals cannot forget traumatic events. Many accounts present differences among these positions as a legitimate debate despite the substantial forensic, survey, and neurological evidence that both demonstrates the capacity for people to exhibit impaired memory for trauma and highlights specific mechanisms. In a recent article, H. G. Pope, M. B. Poliakoff, M. P. Parker, M. Boynes, and J. I. Hudson (2007) hypothesized that if individuals could forget trauma, the phenomenon would appear in world literature prior to 1800. They conducted a contest to generate submissions of examples and determined that dissociative amnesia is a culture-bound syndrome. Their report fails to provide a thorough account of all submissions and the process through which they were all rejected, offers highly questionable literary analyses, and includes several misrepresentations of the state of the science regarding memory for trauma. This response addresses methodological problems with the contest, explores examples of forgetting trauma from literature written before 1800, examines social and historical aspects of the issue, and summarizes the extensive cognitive and neurological data that Pope et al. did not consider. The present article conceptualizes the premise of the contest and the authors' conclusion as symptomatic of a culture affected by biases that include the denial of trauma and its effects.

US$19.90

PMID: 19585333

DOI: 10.1080/15299730902956572


Other references

Inamura, K.; Yokouchi, Y.; Kobayashi, M.; Sakakibara, R.; Ninomiya, H.; Subat, S.; Nagano, H.; Nomura, K.; Okumura, S.; Shibutani, T.; Ishikawa, Y., 2016: WITHDRAWN: Tumor B7-H3 (CD276) expression and smoking history in relation to lung adenocarcinoma prognosis. NlmCategory="UNASSIGNED">The Publisher regrets that this article is an accidental duplication of an article that has already been published in The Journal of Lung Cancer - http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.lungcan.2016.11.013. Please see on...

Keri, S.; Szekeres, G.; Kelemen, O.; Antal, A.; Szendi, I.; Kovacs, Z.; Benedek, G.; Janka, Z., 1998: Abstraction is impaired at the perceptual level in schizophrenic patients. This study investigates category learning in schizophrenia in order to evaluate abstraction abilities at the perceptual level. The participants learned about two categories of geometric shapes. The category exemplars were presented successively. I...

Bolwerk, A.; Seifert, F.; Maihöfner, C., 2014: Altered resting-state functional connectivity in complex regional pain syndrome. This study explored the functional connectivity between brain regions implicated in the default mode network, the sensorimotor cortex (S1/M1), and the intraparietal sulcus (IPS/MIP) at rest in patients with complex regional pain syndrome. It also...

Price, Jc, 1976: The nature of multiple solutions for surface wind speed over the oceans from scatterometer measurements. The satellite SEASAT-A will carry a radar scatterometer in order to measure microwave backscatter from the sea surface. From pairs of radar measurements at angles separated by 90° in azimuth the surface wind speed and direction may be inferred, t...

Poth, J.L.; George, R.P.; Creger, W.P.; Schrier, S.L., 1971: Acute myelogenous leukemia following localized radiotherapy. Archives of Internal Medicine 128(5): 802-805

Regoeczi E.L., 1970: Activation of blood coagulation by epithelial glyco protein. Journal Of Clinical Investigation: 74a-75a

Bachmann, L.; Sperlich, D., 1993: Gradual evolution of a specific satellite DNA family in Drosophila ambigua, Drosophila tristis, and Drosophila obscura. The highly repetitive satelite DNA family "ATOC180" is specific for the three closely related species Drosophila obscura, D. ambigua, and D. tristis but does not occur in their closest relative D. subsilvestris an D. bifasciata. Approxim...

Yong, W.Wei.; Sourial, M.; Farmer, P.J.; Southwell, B.R.; Hutson, J.M., 2007: Does chemical sympathectomy alter the ontogeny of gubernacular migration in vivo?. Testicular descent occurs in several stages, but the exact mechanism remains obscure. Sympathetic nerves have been proposed to have a role by a possible action on developing cremaster muscle, following observations of sympathetic dysfunction in cr...

Makarova, O.V.; Gol'dfarb, D.M., 1979: Inhibition of RNA synthesis in vitro by antibodies against mononucleotides. Antibodies against purine nucleotides were obtained from rabbits immunized with conjugates of bovine serum albumine with AMP or GMP. The antibodies purified by affinity chromatography on nucleoside monophosphate-human serum albumine-Sepharose colu...

Lee, H.; Lee, H.; Kwon, Y.; Lee, J-Ho.; Kim, J.; Shin, M-Kyu.; Kim, S-Hoon.; Bae, H., 2011: Methyl gallate exhibits potent antitumor activities by inhibiting tumor infiltration of CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells. CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory T (Treg) cells play crucial roles in the host response to tumors. Increasing evidence supports the existence of elevated numbers of Treg cells in solid tumors and hematologic malignancies. In this study, the effects of met...