+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Methadone vs. buprenorphine/naloxone during early opioid substitution treatment: a naturalistic comparison of cognitive performance relative to healthy controls

, : Methadone vs. buprenorphine/naloxone during early opioid substitution treatment: a naturalistic comparison of cognitive performance relative to healthy controls. Bmc Clinical Pharmacology 7(): 5-5

Both methadone- and buprenorphine-treated opioid-dependent patients frequently show cognitive deficits in attention, working memory, and verbal memory. However, no study has compared these patient groups with each other during early opioid substitution treatment (OST). Therefore, we investigated attention, working memory, and verbal memory of opioid-dependent patients within six weeks after the introduction of OST in a naturalistic setting and compared to those of healthy controls. The sample included 16 methadone-, 17 buprenorphine/naloxone-treated patients, and 17 healthy controls matched for sex and age. In both groups buprenorphine was the main opioid of abuse during the recent month. Benzodiazepine codependence, recent use, and comedication were also common in both patient groups. Analysis of variance was used to study the overall group effect in each cognitive test. Pair-wise group comparisons were made, when appropriate Methadone-treated patients, as a group, had significantly slower simple reaction time (RT) compared to buprenorphine/naloxone-treated patients. In Go/NoGo RT methadone patients were significantly slower than controls. Both patient groups were significantly debilitated compared to controls in working memory and verbal list learning. Only methadone patients were inferior to controls in story recall. In simple RT and delayed story recall buprenorphine/naloxone patients with current benzodiazepine medication (n = 13) were superior to methadone patients with current benzodiazepine medication (n = 13). When methadone patients were divided into two groups according to their mean dose, the patient group with a low dose (mean 40 mg, n = 8) showed significantly faster simple RT than the high dose group (mean 67 mg, n = 8). Deficits in attention may only be present in methadone-treated early phase OST patients and may be dose-dependent. Working memory deficit is common in both patient groups. Verbal memory deficit may be more pronounced in methadone-treated patients than in buprenorphine/naloxone-treated patients. In sum, to preserve cognitive function in early OST, the use of buprenorphine/naloxone may be more preferable to methadone use of, at least if buprenorphine has been recently abused and when benzodiazepine comedication is used. Longitudinal studies are needed to investigate if the better performance of buprenorphine/naloxone-treated patients is a relatively permanent effect or reflects "only" transient opioid switching effect.


PMID: 17565668

DOI: 10.1186/1472-6904-7-5

Other references

Kupfer, G.; Geyer, G., 1968: Permeabilitatsstudien Basalmembran-Bindegewebs-Praparaten von der Nasenschleim-haut weisser Mause. Anatomischer Anzeiger, 122: 281-287

Stephens, W.E.; Henry, G.H., 1973: Auditory-visual stimuli, spoken-written response mode and task difficulty and activity levels of mildly retarded children. American Journal of Mental Deficiency 77(4): 455-469

Watson, R.D., 1953: Control of root rot by row application of soil fumigants. Early root rot infections are generally concentrated near the cotyledonary node of peas and the transition zone between root and hypocotyl on beans. This observation suggested that fungicidal fumigants placed at the proper level when the seed was...

Borea, P.A.; Bonora, A.; Siniscalchi, A., 1979: Cholesterol esters of the liver, of the plasma and of the lipoproteins of rats poisoned with CCL4. Pharmacological Research Communications 11(5): 403-411

Egert, D.; Maass, H., 1974: Progesterone in the uterus. I. On the question of progesterone metabolism in the uterus of normal rats. Acta Endocrinologica 77(1): 135-149

Farkas, H.; Vermes, E.; Musci, G.; Nador, G.; Horvath, A.; Pinter, A., 1998: The soil pollution research - assessment of the situation of Baranya and Bekes counties in Hungary. The Hungarian National Institute of Environmental Health has collaborated with the local Public Health Service in Baranya and Bekes Counties to produce a database of information concerning operational and abandoned industrial sites as a source of...

Takeya, K., 1950: Studies on tetrabromphenol phthalein ethylesterkalium (TBPE) reaction and tuberculin activity. II. Application for various tuberculin preparations. Kekkaku 25(6): 236-243

Beric A.; Deletis V.; Halter J., 1986: Electrically evoked long latency responses from proximal muscles of the arm in man. Society for Neuroscience Abstracts 12(1): 248

Jansen B.C.P., 1972: Deficiency effects in human beings thiamine. Sebrell, W H Jr And Robert S Harris (Ed ) The Vitamins Chemistry, Physiology, Pathology, Methods, Vol 5 2nd Ed Xviii+468p Illus Academic Press: New York, N Y , U S A ; London, England 148-150

Lamb, C.A.; Bentley, O.G.; Beattie, J.M., 1958: Trace elements. Proceedings of the Conference held at the Ohio Agricultural Experiment Station, Wooster, Ohio, October 14-16, 1957. This symposium, dealing with different aspects of trace element nutrition in plants, animals, and micro-organisms, was held to commemorate the Diamond Jubilee of the Station. Included are papers on: ' Manganese deficiency in soybeans' by...