+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Pragmatic evidence and textual arrangements: a case study of French clinical cancer guidelines

, : Pragmatic evidence and textual arrangements: a case study of French clinical cancer guidelines. Social Science & Medicine 71(4): 685-692

Both critics and supporters of evidence-based medicine view clinical practice guidelines as an important component of this self-defined "new paradigm" whose goal is to rationalize medicine by grounding clinical decision-making in a careful assessment of the medical literature. We present an analysis of the debates within a guideline development group (GDG) that led to the drafting, revision and publication of a French cancer guideline. Our ethnographic approach focuses on the various aspects of the dispositif (or apparatus) that defines the nature and roles of participants, procedures, topics and resources within the GDG. Debates between GDG members are framed (but not dictated) by procedural and methodological rules as well as by the reflexive critical contributions of the GDG members themselves, who justify their (tentative) recommendations by relating to its (possible or intended) audiences. Guideline production work cannot be reduced to an exchange of arguments and to consensus-seeking between pre-defined professional interests. It is about the production of a text in the material sense of the term, i.e. as a set of sentences, paragraphs, statements and formulations that GDG members constantly readjust and rearrange until closure is achieved. As such, guidelines partake in the emergence and stabilization of a new configuration of biomedical knowledge and practices grounded in the establishment of mutually constitutive links between two processes: on the one hand, the re-formatting of clinical trials into a device for producing carefully monitored evidence statements targeting specific populations and clinical indications and, on the other hand, the increasingly pervasive role of regulatory processes.


PMID: 20646809

DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2010.05.019

Other references

Fukuda, Y.; Terashima, S., 2000: Intermediates for the preparation of duocarmycin SA and derivatives thereof, and process for the production of the intermediates. Indole derivatives shown by the formulae (1), (2a) and (2b) ##STR1## (wherein R1 is a protecting group for amino group; R2 is a protecting group for hydroxyl group; R3 is a protecting group for hydroxyl group; R4 is a C1 -C6 linear or branched low...

Ahmad S.; Trepel J.; Glazer R.I., 1992: Protein kinase c isoform specific mediation of multidrug resistance mdr in mdr1 expressing mcf 7 cells. Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 33: 456

Fisher, W.R., 1970: The characterization and occurrence of an Sf 20 serum lipoprotein. Journal of Biological Chemistry 245(4): 877-884

Pochet, L.; Frédérick, Rël.; Masereel, B., 2004: Coumarin and isocoumarin as serine protease inhibitors. Serine proteases are attractive targets for the design of enzyme inhibitors since they are involved in the etiology of several diseases. Within the class of serine proteases, HLE is one of the most destructive enzymes in the body. It is implicated...

Keyes, J.W.; Kline, R.C.; Resinger, W.W.; Rose, E.A.; Koral, K.F.; Rogers, W.L., 1983: Comparison of observer performance reading from a video CRT vs. reading from film. The developing trend for all medical images to be in digital form raises an important question: should diagnostic interpretations be made directly from a CRT or from some form of hard copy recording of the CRT? This question was studied by having...

Wu, Z.-; Deng, P.-; Wu, X.-; Luo, S.-; Gao, Y., 2007: Allelopathic effects of the submerged macrophyte Potamogeton malaianus on Scenedesmus obliquus. Allelopathic effects of the submerged macrophyte Potamogeton malaianus on Scenedesmus obliquus were assessed using a two-phase approach under controlled laboratory conditions. In the co-culture experiment (phase ), the growth of S. obliquus at two...

Tuszyński, J.A.; Dixon, J.M., 2001: Quantitative analysis of the frequency spectrum of the radiation emitted by cytochrome oxidase enzymes. A physical model is proposed that provides a quantitative analysis of the energy emitted by proton flows through mitochondrial walls. The model developed is based on biochemical and biophysical properties of the enzyme cytochrome oxidase and in pa...

Fraga, D.; Hermolin, J.; Fillingame, R.H., 1994: Transmembrane helix-helix interactions in F0 suggested by suppressor mutations to Ala24 - > Asp/Asp61 - > Gly mutant of ATP synthase subunit c. The Journal of Biological Chemistry 269: 62-7

Leszko B.; Pawelski S., 1975: Renal function in polycythemia. Haematologia 9(1-2): 73-78

Callow, J.A.; Callow, M.E.; Ista, L.K.; Lopez, G.; Chaudhury, M.K., 2006: The influence of surface energy on the wetting behaviour of the spore adhesive of the marine alga Ulva linza (synonym Enteromorpha linza). The environmental scanning electron microscope has been used to image the adhesive pads secreted by zoospores of the marine alga Ulva linza as they settle on a rang of self-assembled and grafted monolayers of different wettability, under natural....