+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Teaching first or teaching last: does the timing matter in simulation-based surgical scenarios?

, : Teaching first or teaching last: does the timing matter in simulation-based surgical scenarios?. Journal of Surgical Education 67(6): 432-438

The optimal timing of instruction in simulation-based scenarios remains unclear. We sought to determine how varying the timing of instruction, either before (teaching first) or after (teaching last) the simulation, affects knowledge outcomes of surgical trainees. We conducted a pretest/posttest crossover study in which fourth-year medical students and general surgery residents (PGY 1-3) participated in 3 instructional modules, each repeated twice in consecutive weeks: endocrine surgery (sessions 1 and 2), trauma resuscitation (sessions 3 and 4), and team training (sessions 5 and 6). Each session comprised 3 cases, each involving a prescenario briefing, a simulated scenario, and a postscenario debriefing. The timing of instruction varied between sessions. For the teaching-first sequence (sessions 1, 4, and 6), participants received a lecture during each prescenario briefing. In the teaching-last sequence (sessions 2, 3, and 5), trainees received an identical lecture during the postscenario debriefings. We assessed attitudes and knowledge using a postsession survey and identical 10-question multiple-choice tests at the start (pretest) and end (posttest) of each session, respectively. The mean differences in knowledge scores between groups were analyzed with repeated-measures analysis of variance (ANOVA). Forty-nine participants (11 medical students and 38 surgical residents) attended at least 1 session, providing 76 observations. Mean pretest scores were equivalent (p > 0.05). The change in scores from pretest to posttest varied between the 2 groups (p = 0.002). The mean posttest score was 8.24 (standard error [SE], 0.29) for the teaching-last group and 6.68 (SE, 0.27) for the teaching-first group (mean difference, 1.56; 95% confidence interval, 0.79-2.33). Both teaching-last and teaching-first group participants preferentially rated debriefings and scenarios, respectively, as the better learning experience. Participants who received instruction after simulated scenarios achieved higher mean knowledge scores than those who received instruction before simulated scenarios. Cognitive overload, stress, or activation of prior knowledge could all be involved as causal mechanisms.


PMID: 21156304

DOI: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2010.05.001

Other references

Konno, C.; Sugiyama, K.; Kano, M.; Takahashi, M.; Hikino, H., 1984: Isolation and hypoglycaemic activity of panaxans A, B, C, D and E, glycans of Panax ginseng roots. Planta Medica 50(5): 434-436

Heinzl, S., 1995: The value of colposcopy in assessment of intraepithelial neoplasia of the lower genital tract. Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics 257(1-4): 425-430

Rackwitz H R.; Scheit K H., 1974: The synthesis of purine nucleoside 6 sulfonates. Chemische Berichte 107(7): 2284-2294

Gaede, H.C.; Yau, W-Ming.; Gawrisch, K., 2006: Electrostatic contributions to indole-lipid interactions. The role of electrostatic forces in indole-lipid interactions was studied by (1)H and (2)H NMR in ether- and ester-linked phospholipid bilayers with incorporated indole. Indole-ring-current-induced (1)H NMR chemical shifts of lipid resonances in b...

Asada, Makoto, 1994: The role of rac p21 G protein in the O-2- generating NADPH oxidase complex. Japanese Journal of Pharmacology 64(SUPPL 1): 56P

Cheever, K., 1994: Fractured jaw--your role after surgery. Nursing 24(6): 32f-32f

Jun, S-Hee.; Lee, E-Jung.; Yook, S-Won.; Kim, H-Ee.; Kim, H-Won.; Koh, Y-Hag., 2010: A bioactive coating of a silica xerogel/chitosan hybrid on titanium by a room temperature sol-gel process. A bioactive coating consisting of a silica xerogel/chitosan hybrid was applied to Ti at room temperature as a novel surface treatment for metallic implants. A crack-free thin layer (<2 microm) was coated on Ti with a chitosan content of >30...

Petters, RM.; Stefanelli, J., 1983: Developmental arrest of endoparasitoid wasp larvae (Nemeritis canescens Grav.) caused by an ectoparasitoid wasp (Bracon hebetor Say). The effect on the development of Venturia canescens (Grav.) (Nemeritis canescens) of paralysis in its larval host caused by Bracon hebetor Say was investigated. The 2 species often occur together at the same site and attack the same hosts. Females...

Coon, M.J.; Estabrook, R.W., 2002: Ronald W. Estabrook: gifted scientist with the same versatile, energetic, and colorful qualities as cytochrome P450. Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics 409(1): 16-17

Tsurumi, T., 2011: Introduction to the special issue on the joint meeting of the 19th IEEE International Symposium on the Applications of Ferroelectrics and the 10th European Conference on the Applications of Polar Dielectrics. The joint meeting of the 19th IEEE International Symposium on the Applications of Ferroelectrics and the 10th European Conference on the Applications of Polar Dielectrics took place in Edinburgh from August 9-12, 2010. The conference was attended...