+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

The Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test under scrutiny

, : The Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test under scrutiny. Statistics in Medicine 28(10): 1487-1497

The Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney (WMW) test is often used to compare the means or medians of two independent, possibly nonnormal distributions. For this problem, the true significance level of the large sample approximate version of the WMW test is known to be sensitive to differences in the shapes of the distributions. Based on a wide ranging simulation study, our paper shows that the problem of lack of robustness of this test is more serious than is thought to be the case. In particular, small differences in variances and moderate degrees of skewness can produce large deviations from the nominal type I error rate. This is further exacerbated when the two distributions have different degrees of skewness. Other rank-based methods like the Fligner-Policello (FP) test and the Brunner-Munzel (BM) test perform similarly, although the BM test is generally better. By considering the WMW test as a two-sample T test on ranks, we explain the results by noting some undesirable properties of the rank transformation. In practice, the ranked samples should be examined and found to sufficiently satisfy reasonable symmetry and variance homogeneity before the test results are interpreted.


PMID: 19247980

DOI: 10.1002/sim.3561

Other references

Winnicki, K., 2009: Second code, or what determines actively transcribed regions and replication origins. Although each cell of a complex organism is governed by the same genome, cells which form different tissues vary in epigenetic codes that are responsible for various gene expression. These codes, through their influence on chromatin structure, det...

Shah, B.; Ashok, L.; Sujatha, G.P., 2010: Evaluation of salivary cortisol and psychological factors in patients with oral lichen planus. Lichen planus is a relatively common chronic inflammatory disease of oral mucosa and skin. Cortisol, also called as "stress hormone", has been used as an indicator in various stress evaluation studies. Salivary cortisol measurement is an...

D.Aquino, U.M., 1954: Treatment of framboesia. I. Recent framboesia treated by single and double dose of 600,000 units of N,N'-dibenzylethylenediamine, dipenicillin G. Revista Brasileira de Medicina 11(8): 547-550

Duisenov, S.T., 1992: The near Aral region is the zone of ecological disaster. The disastrous ecological situation in the near Aral region and the causes of it are reviewed. Ways of overcoming this situation are suggested.

Tandon, M.; Pandey, C.K., 2012: Myocardial oxidative stress protection with sevoflurane versus propofol. European Journal of Anaesthesiology 29(6): 296-7; Author Reply 297-8

Tikkanen, H.I.kka Helenius; Haahtela, T., 1996: Pulmonary functions of healthy elite runners in winter and pollen-season out door running test. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 28(5 SUPPL ): S90

de Lara-Castells, Mía.Pilar.; Bartolomei, M.; Mitrushchenkov, A.O.; Stoll, H., 2015: Transferability and accuracy by combining dispersionless density functional and incremental post-Hartree-Fock theories: Noble gases adsorption on coronene/graphene/graphite surfaces. The accuracy and transferability of the electronic structure approach combining dispersionless density functional theory (DFT) [K. Pernal et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 263201 (2009)] with the method of increments [H. Stoll, J. Chem. Phys. 97, 8449...

Hatzoglou, A.; Bakogeorgou, E.; Castanas, E., 1996: The antiproliferative effect of opioid receptor agonists on the T47D human breast cancer cell line, is partially mediated through opioid receptors. In the present study, we investigated the action of opioid receptor agonists on the proliferation of cells of the T47D human breast cancer cell line, grown in the absence of exogenously added steroids and growth factors. We found that the opioid r...

Pokrovskiĭ, V.I.; Smagulov, K.Z.; Mashilov, V.P.; Iushchuk, N.D.; Malyshev, N.A.; Abubakirov, V.T.; Brodov, L.E.; Bykova, R.N.; Lubova, V.V., 1993: The status of and outlook for improving the diagnosis of acute intestinal infections at the prehospital stage. Comprehensive analysis of the incidence of acute enteric infections (AEI) in Moscow over the period of 1985-1990 was made. The analysis demonstrated serious drawbacks in the diagnosis of a number of AEI, including alimentary toxicoinfections, salm...

Zemcov A.; Risberg J.; Barclay L.L.; Blass J.P., 1984: Diagnosis of alzheimers disease and multi infarct dementia by regional cerebral blood flow compared to clinical classification. Fieschi, C , G L Lenzi And C W Loeb (Ed ) Monographs in Neural Sciences, Vol 11 Effects Of Aging on Regulation Of Cerebral Blood Flow And Metabolism; 2nd Satellite Symposium, San Remo, Italy, June 30-July 1, 1983 Xiii+258p S Karger: Basel, Switzerland; New York, N Y , Usa Illus 104-106