geoscience.net logo
+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

The ethical boundaries of patient and advocate influence on DSM-5


, : The ethical boundaries of patient and advocate influence on DSM-5. Harvard Review of Psychiatry 21(6): 334-344

: This article discusses the relationship between disease-advocacy groups and the revision process for the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. We discuss three examples in which patient-advocacy groups engaged with the DSM-5 revision process: Autism Speaks' worries about the contraction of the autism diagnostic category, the National Alliance on Mental Illness's support for the inclusion of psychosis risk syndrome, and B4U-ACT's critique of the expansion of pedophilia. After a descriptive examination of the cases, we address two prescriptive questions. First, what is the ethical basis for patient and advocate influence on DSM diagnoses? Second, how should the American Psychiatric Association proceed when this influence comes into conflict with other goals of the revision process? We argue that the social effects of, and values embedded in, psychiatric classification, combined with patient and advocates' experiential knowledge about those aspects of diagnosis, ethically justify advocate influence in relation to those particular matters. However, this advocate influence ought to have limits, which we briefly explore. Our discussion has implications for discussions of disease categories as loci for social movements, for analyses of the expanding range of processes and institutions that advocacy groups target, and for broader questions regarding the aims of the DSM revision process.

US$19.90

PMID: 24201823

DOI: 10.1097/HRP.0000000000000010


Other references

Castillejo, N.; Martínez-Hernández, Gés.Benito.; Monaco, K.; Gómez, P.A.; Aguayo, E.; Artés, F.; Artés-Hernández, F., 2016: Preservation of bioactive compounds of a green vegetable smoothie using short time-high temperature mild thermal treatment. NlmCategory="UNASSIGNED">Smoothies represent an excellent and convenient alternative to promote the daily consumption of fruit and vegetables in order to obtain their health-promoting benefits. Accordingly, a green fresh vegetables sm...

Hacking, J.C.; Flower, C.D., 1995: Causes and investigation of increasing dyspnoea in rheumatoid arthritis. Fibrosing alveolitis and bronchiolitis obliterans are two of the many pulmonary manifestations of the connective tissue disorders. When shortness of breath is the main complaint, it is often difficult to diagnose the individual causative lesion fr...

Rosenthal, R.L., 1982: Serum acid phosphatase in Gaucher disease before and after splenectomy. Progress in Clinical and Biological Research 95: 279-284

Sealey, J.E., 1991: Plasma renin activity and plasma prorenin assays. Sensitivity and accuracy are essential features of an assay of plasma renin activity (PRA) because the normal concentration of PRA is only 1 pmol/L, and subnormal concentrations have diagnostic relevance. Conditions for blood collection need to be...

Gentili, M.E., 2001: Is difficult mask ventilation only correlated to the physical status of the patient?. Anesthesiology 94(5): 935; Author Reply 937-935; Author Reply 937

Barichello, R.R., 2000: A review of tariff rate quota administration in Canadian agriculture. A model of efficient quota administration is used to analyse Canada's tariff rate quota (TRQ) administration. After examining the operation of the Canadian TRQ system for its 21 TRQs, conclusions are drawn. In general this system has worked w...

Even, S.; Fontaine, L.; Lindley, N.; Cocaign Bousquet, M., 2001: Quantitative analysis of glycolysis regulation in Lactococcus lactis: from gene to enzyme. Transcripts of the sequenced genes encoding enzymes of central metabolism of L. lactis have been quantified using slot blot technology. Methods of quantification and data analysis were optimized to obtain a quantitative approach with high sensitiv...

Griffin, K.J.; Harris, S.; Tang, T.Y.; Skelton, N.; Reed, J.B.; Harris, A.M., 2010: Incidence of contralateral occult inguinal hernia found at the time of laparoscopic trans-abdominal pre-peritoneal (TAPP) repair. Trans-abdominal laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair allows rapid assessment and exploration of the contralateral groin and repair of an occult hernia. Although previous studies have shown that the totally extra-peritoneal (TEP) hernia repair can b...

Hahn P., 1981: Development of carnitine synthesis from gamma butyro betaine in the rat. The ability of the rat liver to synthesize camitine from .gamma.-butyrobetaine increases from low values in the fetus to adult values on the 8th day after birth. The rate of synthesis of carnitine is greater when determined in the high-speed super...

Grigor' ev, A.A., 1974: The role of gonadotropic hormones in the controlled breeding of caged female sables. Levels of LH and FSH were studied in the urine of 40 females during the breeding season. Mature females ovulated spontaneously, showing a preovulatory rise in FSH (to 7.81 plus or minus 0.6 IU/ml), and an ovulatory peak of LH (26.5 plus or minus 2...