+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Thermodynamics and metabolic advantage of weight loss diets

, : Thermodynamics and metabolic advantage of weight loss diets. Metabolic Syndrome and Related Disorders 1(3): 209-219

Published reports show that low carbohydrate weight loss diets provide a metabolic advantage, a greater weight loss per calorie consumed compared to isocaloric high carbohydrate diets. These reports have not been refuted but rather largely ignored, presumably because of the apparent violation of the laws of thermodynamics ("a calorie is a calorie"). In this review, we show that there is no such violation of thermodynamic laws. Energy utilization of different diets depends on the chemical pathway taken and a metabolic analysis of the efficiency of different pathways reveals large differences. Likewise, thermogenesis produced by diets of different macronutrient composition varies widely. We present a plausible mechanism that depends on the inefficiency of metabolic cycles and, in particular, protein turnover. A low carbohydrate diet makes demands on protein turnover for gluconeogenesis. From a theoretical point of view,energy balance between two diets is to be expected only if the subjects have the same final physiologic state, and only if all of the changes contributing to the energy, heat, work and chemical effects are known. Most diet experiments do not conform to this ideal. There is no theoretical contradiction in metabolic advantage and no theoretical barrier to accepting reports describing this effect.


PMID: 18370664

DOI: 10.1089/154041903322716688

Other references

Kidd, K.; Cusi, K.; Mueller, R.; Goodner, M.; Boyes, B.; Hoy, E., 2005: Detection and identification of significant ANAs in previously determined ANA negative samples. An antinuclear antibody (ANA) substrate transfected with the cDNA to hyperexpress the 60 kD SS-A/Ro antigen (HEp-2000) has been shown to detect anti-SS-A/Ro antibodies missed by standard HEp-2 and other immunoassays. Despite this evidence, many la...

Latil, A.; Cussenot, O.; Fournier, G.; Lidereau, R., 1997: Infrequent allelic imbalance at the major susceptibility HPC1 locus in sporadic prostate tumours. International Journal of Cancer 71(6): 1118-1118

Badia-Flores, J.; Muñoz Barradas, F., 1980: Treatment of chronic polyarthritis with acemetacin and indomethacin. In a controlled double blind study the therapeutic efficacy and tolerability of equimolar doses of [1-(p-chlorobenzoyl)-5-methoxy-2-methylindol-3-acetoxy] acetic acid (acemetacin, TV 1322, Rantudil) and indometacin (acemetacin: 180 mg/day, indomet...

Wiederhold M.D.; O.D.W., 1992: Synthesis of oxidized cholesterol by u937 cells a human macrophage cell line in tissue culture. FASEB Journal 6(5): A1615

Borgulya J.; Daly J.J.; Schonholzer P.; Bernauer K., 1984: Rearrangement of derivatives of 1 3 dithian 5 amine into bicyclic 2 thiazolidines crystal structures of cis and trans 1 2 aryl 1 3 dithian 5 yl 2 thioureas and cis and trans 5 aryl 3 imino 7 7a dihydro 1h 3h 5h thiazolo 3 4 c thiazoles. Under conditions normally applied to transform thioureas into the corresponding carbodiimides, cis- and trans-1-(2-aryl-1,3-dithian-5-yl)-2-thioureas undergo a rearrangement to 5-aryl-3-imino-7,7a-dihydro-1H,3H,5H-thiazolo[3,4-c]thiazoles with cis...

Bailey, J.; Cassidy, A., 1996: Using nursing theory to introduce change in practice. This article outlines the theoretical basis of nursing using Carper's (1978) fundamental patterns of knowing and explains how this theory can be integrated with practice. The authors also describe how Carper's theory was used to introduc...

Tyankova, L., 1967: On the origin of free proline in organs of wheat plants affected entirely or partially by drought. C R Acad Bulg Sci 20(9): 955-958

Cattaneo, M.G.; D'atri, F.; Vicentini, L.M., 1998: Mechanisms of mitogen-activated protein kinase activation by nicotine in small-cell lung carcinoma cells. We have previously reported that nicotine stimulates cell proliferation of three small-cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) cell lines by activating nicotinic receptors of the neuronal type. Here we report that, in the GLC-8 SCLC cell line, nicotine stimula...

Yaroshevsky, P.E., 1930: The biological method of sugar beet breeding and its argumentation. A brief outline of the breeding methods and the points on which selection is based. Self-fertile genotypes are looked for from all parental families. In addition to this, constant selection of parent pairs and groups is practised, so as to preserv...

Zhiqi Zhao; Congqiang Liu; Yingkai Xiao; Yunchao Lang, 2003: Geochemical study of boron isotopes in the process of loess weathering. SCIENCE CHINA Earth Sciences 46(2): 106-116