+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Interrater Reliability and Diagnostic Performance of Subjective Evaluation of Sublingual Microcirculation Images by Physicians and Nurses: A Multicenter Observational Study

, : Interrater Reliability and Diagnostic Performance of Subjective Evaluation of Sublingual Microcirculation Images by Physicians and Nurses: A Multicenter Observational Study. Shock 44(3): 239-244

This was a cross-sectional multicenter study to investigate the ability of physicians and nurses from three different countries to subjectively evaluate sublingual microcirculation images and thereby discriminate normal from abnormal sublingual microcirculation based on flow and density abnormalities. Forty-five physicians and 61 nurses (mean age, 36 ± 10 years; 44 males) from three different centers in The Netherlands (n = 61), Uruguay (n = 12), and Japan (n = 33) were asked to subjectively evaluate a sample of 15 microcirculation videos randomly selected from an experimental model of endotoxic shock in pigs. All videos were first analyzed offline using the A.V.A. software by an independent, experienced investigator and were categorized as good, bad, or very bad microcirculation based on the microvascular flow index, perfused capillary density, and proportion of perfused capillaries. Then, the videos were randomly assigned to the examiners, who were instructed to subjectively categorize each image as good, bad, or very bad. An interrater analysis was performed, and sensitivity and specificity tests were calculated to evaluate the proportion of A.V.A. score abnormalities that the examiners correctly identified. The κ statistics indicated moderate agreement in the evaluation of microcirculation abnormalities using three categories, i.e., good, bad, or very bad (κ = 0.48), and substantial agreement using two categories, i.e., normal (good) and abnormal (bad or very bad) (κ = 0.66). There was no significant difference between the κ three and κ two statistics. We found that the examiner's subjective evaluations had good diagnostic performance and were highly sensitive (84%; 95% confidence interval, 81%-86%) and specific (87%; 95% confidence interval, 84%-90%) for sublingual microcirculatory abnormalities as assessed using the A.V.A. software. The subjective evaluations of sublingual microcirculation by physicians and nurses agreed well with a conventional offline analysis and were highly sensitive and specific for sublingual microcirculatory abnormalities.


PMID: 26009822

DOI: 10.1097/SHK.0000000000000401

Other references

Hagenaars C.E.; Kraan A.A.M.V.D.; Kawilarang E.W.M.; Visser J.W.M.; Nijweide P.J., 1988: Osteoclast differentiation from cloned pluripotent hemopoietic stem cells. Calcified Tissue International 42(SUPPL): A5

Li, Z.; Santhanam, P.; Coles, C.D.; Lynch, M.Ellen.; Hamann, S.; Peltier, S.; Hu, X., 2011: Increased "default mode" activity in adolescents prenatally exposed to cocaine. Prenatal cocaine exposure (PCE) is associated with attention/arousal dysregulation and possible inefficiencies in some cognitive functions. However, the neurobiological bases of these teratogenic effects have not been well characterized. Because a...

Kolb, W.P.; Müller-Eberhard, H.J., 1975: Neoantigens of the membrane attack complex of human complement. The membrane attack complex of complement is a fusion product of five complement proteins: C5b, C6, C7, C8, and C9. The complex causes complement-dependent cell membrane damage. It is assembled following complement activation both on the target ce...

Uromeihy Ali, 1997: Sinkholes and their effect on the stability of the Lar Dam. Dam Construction in karst terrain immediately raises questions concerning incipient sinkhole formation. In such area prior to the design and construction of a dam, an intensive site investigation should be carried out to identify sinkhole distribu...

Hsu,; Chen,, 2000: Genomic structure and alternative spliced variants of human CaMKK b gene. Molecular Biology of the Cell 11(Supplement): 334a, Dec

dos Santos, R.Mattos.; de Jesus, C.Márcio.Nóbrega.; Trindade Filho, Jé.Carlos.Souza.; Trindade, Jé.Carlos.Souza.; de Camargo, Jão.Lauro.Viana.; Rainho, Cáudia.Aparecida.; Rogatto, S.Regina., 2008: PSA and androgen-related gene (AR, CYP17, and CYP19) polymorphisms and the risk of adenocarcinoma at prostate biopsy. The aim of the present study was to examine the impact of polymorphisms in prostate-specific antigen (PSA) and androgen-related genes (AR, CYP17, and CYP19) on prostate cancer (PCa) risk in selected high-risk patients who underwent prostate biopsy...

Kang, Y.; Yan, X.; Li, L.; Zhang, Q.; Zeng, L.; Luo, J., 2014: Daphnia magna may serve as a powerful tool in screening endocrine disruption chemicals (EDCs). Environmental Science & Technology 48(2): 881-882

Nunes, M.C.N.; Brecht, J.K.; Sargent, S.A.; Morais, A.M.M.B., 1995: Effects of delays to cooling and wrapping on strawberry quality (cv. Sweet Charlie). Strawberries (cv. Sweet Charlie) were wrapped with PVC polymeric film and forced-air precooled after delays of 0, 6 or 8 h at 30 degrees C to study the effect of delaying precooling on physical and chemical quality characteristics. Non-wrapped fru...

Anonymous, 1988: Differences in the effectiveness of levothyroxine preparations. Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift 113(26): 1081-1084

Upchurch, D.M.; Levy-Storms, L.; Sucoff, C.A.; Aneshensel, C.S., 1998: Gender and ethnic differences in the timing of first sexual intercourse. This study estimated the effects of gender and ethnic differences on the risk of first intercourse (FI) among a population-based sample of Los Angeles County youths aged 12-17 years. Longitudinal surveys were conducted during 1992-94 and 1994-95....