geoscience.net logo
+ Resolve Article
+ Follow Us
Follow on FacebookFollow on Facebook
Follow on TwitterFollow on Twitter

+ Translate
+ Subscribe to Site Feed
GeoScience Most Shared ContentMost Shared Content

Scepticism and hope in a complex predicament: People with addictions deliberate about neuroscience


, : Scepticism and hope in a complex predicament: People with addictions deliberate about neuroscience. International Journal on Drug Policy 32(): 34-43

According to the 'brain disease model of addiction', addiction is a chronic condition the symptoms of which reflect persistent changes in neural functioning produced by long-term drug use. Scholars have argued both for and against the validity and usefulness of this way of conceptualising addiction, which has been variously described as emancipatory and detrimental to addicted persons. In this paper we explore how people with addictions make sense of the brain disease concept and the extent to which they find it useful. We conducted 44 semi-structured interviews with persons in treatment for drug and alcohol addiction recruited through a variety of channels. Transcripts were analysed by combining a health identity approach with thematic analysis. We describe participants' understandings of how they became addicted and what role, if any, neurobiological conceptions play in their explanations. Our findings highlight the hopeful and sceptical viewpoints of addicted individuals on the value of addiction neuroscience ideas and neurotechnologies. These viewpoints shed some light on the diverse and divergent ways that people with addictions make sense of neurobiological ideas and technologies. It also describes when, and how, neurobiological explanations and the 'brain disease' model can be helpful to addicted persons. Some of the limitations of the brain disease model become apparent in the complex ways in which neurobiological explanations and labels are incorporated into lay understandings. In order to be more useful to addicted persons, neurobiological explanations should be provided as part of a more complex explanation of addiction and the brain than the BDMA offers, and should not be given a 'disease' label.

US$19.90

PMID: 27142450

DOI: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2016.03.004


Other references

Chung, S.Phil.; Cho, J.; Park, Y.Seok.; Kang, H.Goo.; Kim, C.Woong.; Song, K.Jeong.; Lim, H.; Cho, G.Chong., 2011: Effects of script-based role play in cardiopulmonary resuscitation team training. The purpose of this study is to compare the cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) team dynamics and performance between a conventional simulation training group and a script-based training group. This was a prospective randomised controlled trial of...

Kmietowicz, Z., 2015: E-cigarettes latest: users on the up but rules tighten. Bmj 349: G6444-G6444

Thornton, D.H.; Pattison, M., 1975: Comparison of vaccines against infectious bursal disease. A comparative study was undertaken of 9 products from 7 different sources intended for use as vaccines against infectious bursal disease of chickens (IBD). A range of properties was found in laboratory tests for safety, efficacy and immunosuppress...

Oh, J.Soo.; Kim, K.Nyun.; An, S.Su.; Pennant, W.A.; Kim, H.Jin.; Gwak, S-Jung.; Yoon, D.Heum.; Lim, M.Hyun.; Choi, B.Hyune.; Ha, Y., 2011: Cotransplantation of mouse neural stem cells (mNSCs) with adipose tissue-derived mesenchymal stem cells improves mNSC survival in a rat spinal cord injury model. The low survival rate of graft stem cells after transplantation into recipient tissue is a major obstacle for successful stem cell therapy. After transplantation into the site of spinal cord injury, the stem cells face not only hypoxia due to low...

Fink, A.L.; Wildi, E., 1974: Conformational change associated with the acylation of alpha-chymotrypsin by N-acetyl-L-phenylalanine methyl ester. Journal of Biological Chemistry 249(19): 6087-6089

Karlsson, F.A.; Dahlberg, P.A.; Wålinder, O., 1981: Activation of membrane-bound adenylcyclase by thyroid stimulating antibodies. Human thyroid plasma membranes isolated from thyroids from patients with Graves' disease or non-toxic nodular goitres produced, under basal conditions, about 100 pmol cAMP per mg membrane protein in 30 min at 37 degrees C. TSH increased the m...

Yang, L.; Ma, X.; Lyone, A.; Zou, J.; Blackburn, M.L.; Pan, J.; Yang, D.; Matsushita, H.; Mei, B.; Zielinska-Kwiatkowska, A.; Chansky, H.A., 2009: Proper expression of helix-loop-helix protein Id2 is important to chondrogenic differentiation of ATDC5 cells. The process of chondrogenesis can be mimicked in vitro by insulin treatment of mouse ATDC5 chondroprogenitor cells. To identify novel factors that are involved in the control of chondrogenesis, we carried out a large-scale screening through retrov...

Bell, A.F.; Cottrell-Uormer, W., 1932: Method for isolating the leaf scald organism. The isolation of Phytomonas albilineans, the causal organism of leaf scald of sugar-cane, is difficult on account of its slow rate of growth and the necessity for heavy sowing. The writers have found that the organism thrives better in a medium in...

Onof, C.; Townend, J., 2004: Modelling 5-minute rainfall extremes. Two disaggregators used to downscale hourly rainfall depths to 5-minute time-steps, are described and compared. STORMPAC is a micro-disaggregator that generates 5-minute depths adding up to the given hourly intensities. CASCADE is a macro-disaggre...

Kang, B.C.; Zhou, K.; Lai, Y.L.; Hong, C.B., 1996: Experimental asthma developed by room air contamination with cockroach allergen. To study the asthmatogenic effect of certain airborne elements of the home environment, we studied a group of guinea pigs exposed to aerosolized cockroach allergen (CRa) and side-stream cigarette (S-SC) smoke. Four groups of guinea pigs were expos...